Redwall is a very violent series (I'm pretty sure we all know that) but I'm curious how Netflix is going to handle the their upcoming adaption. Given the treatment that Over the Garden Wall had, I'm optimistic that there won't be an abundance of talking down to the audience. Email. The first will be an animated feature film adaptation of the first Redwall book, which tells the story of the young Abbey mouse Matthias and his journey to become a warrior when the dreaded Cluny the Scourge attacks Redwall … Because of that it's my opinion at least that they should be faithful adaptations, including being faithful to the violence, but it should be shot in such a way that it's not to the level of being extreme or gratuitous. Haha, awesome. Netflix recently announced they will be adapting Brian Jacques’ Redwall novels with Over The Garden Wall creator Patrick McHale. We welcome respectful dialogue related to speculative fiction in literature, games, film, and the wider world. Since let's face it most of the fans are probably adults now. I'll always have a mouse-sized hole in my heart for Redwall, though. Netflix is adapting a classic series of books into movies and TV shows. There is definitely death, blood, beheadings, and so on but it isn't excessively violent. Yeah see your point but Redwall does have some very violent scenes and some of the more brutal scenes may be a bit much for some viewers. Redwall is a very violent series (I'm pretty sure we all know that) but I'm curious how Netflix is going to handle the their upcoming adaption. like panning away and showing the shadows/silhouettes of what's happening, so you get the idea, but it's not gory. Redwall Abbey is once again in danger. It even stars talking animals! Washington: Famous English writer Brian Jacques’ much-loved books ‘Redwall’ are being adapted into a feature film and TV series by online streaming platform Netflix. r/eulalia: A community to discuss the book series Redwall by Brian Jacques. /r/Fantasy is the internet's largest discussion forum for the greater Speculative … I feel that scenes like that are a bit much for young audiences. It had some brutal parts but was not worse than Redwall. still have all of them on my bookshelf back home! The streaming service has landed the rights to Brian Jacques' Redwall book series. But Redwall is for children and I would hate if they would make it completely for adults, so I'd rather have them censor some of the violence but stay as close to the original as possible. I think your two options are way too limited. However, I have high high hopes for a redwall series from Netflix due to the stellar job they’ve done with adapting Winx, which I admittedly watched as the animated series as a much too old teenager, Witcher (other than the costumes) with a perfect game/book medley, and watership down. Damn. I sure wish Netflix worked on Linux now. Me too, even thought it didn't really make sense. 1.3m members in the Fantasy community. I've got… most of them, I think, but I suspect I haven't actually read all of them. Yeah that's gonna be hard to get away with in a PG setting. I'm assuming you know that there's going to be a Netflix adaption of Redwall (if you don't then here) Redwall is coming to Netflix: where to start for kids (and adults) | Books | The Guardian. :(. For Redwall! Kids need to be able to watch it. Also cheesethief being impaled with a crossbow bolt with blood everywhere, cluny's tail end being cut off and seeing asmodeous being literally decapitated was in the old animated series too. Based on the 22-book children’s series that was published from 1986 through 2011, the books span generations of sword-fighting anthropomorphic mice, rabbits, badgers, and other woodland creatures living at the titular Redwall … Because if they keep certain deaths and not others it would make me wonder why does Blackgut live and Cheesethief die? They are excellent books and some of my favourites of all time, but they are definitely not adult fiction. good memories. But it's extremely fun and a pretty easy read. Netflix and Penguin Random House Children's UK are teaming up to adapt Brian Jacques' Redwall books as both a film and an event series. I personally can see Netflix doing one of 2 things here. Living things both suffer and die; death and violence are both core considerations of the series. Truthfully I'm fine with it being a PG but I don't want them to make it super kid friendly to the point of being "Only for kids". Look at things like The Lion King; there are at least two "fights" in the movie and characters explicitly die, but they don't need to be shown in gory detail to get the point across. I think this would be a great middle ground, as reading about violence and seeing it on screen are different experiences for a child, and while Jacques does describe a lot of violent stuff, he doesn't really go into detail about the gore. "See you...in the next dimension." Loved the Redwall series and I think I read every book. If it goes PG-13 I'd be saying Redwall went way too far over the top; it's a series for kids. It is also the title of the first book of the series, published in 1986, as well as the name of the Abbey featured in the book, and is the name of an animated TV series based on three of the novels (Redwall, Mattimeo, and Martin the Warrior), which first aired in 1999. Redwall, Brian Jacques’ fantasy novels about heroic anthropomorphic animals, is coming to Netflix in a new film and TV show. You can have violence without blood and gore, and without making something "for adults". As per Variety, Netflix has secured a new rights deal with Penguin Random House Children in order to adapt the popular books into movies and series. Redwall has plenty of violence but is hardly an "adult" series, so to speak. Tumblr. The streaming service announced on Twitter that Patrick McHale, the creator of Over The Garden Wall, is behind the project. Maybe use some camera tricks to get those scenes across, like panning away and showing the shadows/silhouettes of what's happening, so you get the idea, but it's not gory. So I feel that a least PG-13 would be good for the more violent scenes. I personally can see Netflix doing one of 2 things here. It would make sense since most of the people who liked Redwall as a kid are grown up now. It's been around a decade since I was a kid reading the Redwall series so my memory is lacking in details but I can't for the life of me remember any mention of the shield and armour Matthias wore in the original Redwall novel in any prior or subsequent books. I’m already preparing myself for the feast scenes.” […] Netflix made the announcement via their NxOnNetflix Twitter account. Redwall is a series of children's fantasy novels by British writer Brian Jacques, published from 1986 to 2011. Some violence is fine to show kids but not to the point of over doing it. Of course I don't want to rely too much on OTGW as a comparison, as that's a high bar to hold up to, but this is also something that shows through in Adventure Time, which is much more flippant, but still manages plenty of good WTF moments. If anyone is interested in a work similar to Redwall for adults, I highly recommend the novella The Builders, by Daniel Polansky. The fact that Netflix are unusually going down the animated route (rather than some sort of hybrid live-action) for both the Redwall standalone and the … It's like a western but with animals, and it's definitely not for kids. ... help Reddit App Reddit coins Reddit premium Reddit gifts. Netflix has acquired the rights to all 22 books in Brian Jacques' fantasy series Redwall, marking the first time that rights to the entire series have been purchased by … Press J to jump to the feed. As Variety reports, Brian Jacques’ beloved Redwall book series is being adapted by Netflix into an animated series and feature film.. From 1986 until his death in 2011, Jacques wrote 22 books set amongst the anthropomorphic denizens of Redwall Abbey and Mossflower Wood. That said, I think the old show had characters run through with swords, it just wasn't bloody. The blade sticking out of his back showed under his cloak, and there was a gross noise. Also a good series. The streamer announced Wednesday morning that it has partnered with Penguin Random House Children’s UK to produce animated film and TV projects based on Brian Jacques' Redwall novels. The cartoon had to do quite a bit of censoring to be able to air for kids the first time. But Idk about the Avater thing. The Redwall series by Brian Jacques is being adapted by Netflix, thanks to a deal with Penguin Random House UK that includes the rights to the entire series of books, ... Netflix to Develop Redwall Feature Film and Series Based on the Books . those books are what got me back into reading as a kid. There are other fantasy shows that seem to utilize blood-less fights, which I think helps a lot to tone down the violence for a kids show. It was us and probably two other kids watching a VHS on a crappy TV, and I thought it was probably the best show I'd ever seen. The TV series will follow Martin the Warrior’s story, whereas the movie will be based on the series’ first book, Redwall.. Big news! I didn't even remember until now that a friend and I went to Barnes & Noble to see someone screen the first episode. For example, the part where a bunch of Cluny's soldiers get boiled alive. It could be Lord of the Rings PG-13 style. I'm all for not talking down to kids but there should defiantly be limits to what you can put in a U rated movie. In addition to the complaints over the sharp good species/bad species divide, another thing I hope is clarified/modified is whether humans do or do not exist in this world. If for no other reason than pronouncing squirrels "squiddles". Things like blood and showing characters getting wounded should be shown, but not things like, say, someone getting impaled or decapitated. The central location (which doesn't appear in every book) is a pagan abbey called Redwall, in a quiet, forested country called Mossflower, where several tribes and clans of woodland folk – mice, rabbits, hedgehogs, otters, squirrels, moles, shrews – live peacefully at a medieval level. Or they could censor the more violent scenes from the books a little. that would be awesome :D. I am really becoming a fan of the tapestry endings. option 1: They censor it even more then the show and make it at least PG-13. After all of these years, Brian Jacques’ beloved Redwall series is getting the full-on Netflix adaptation.According to Deadline, it’s not just the single book either – they’ve netted the entire series courtesy Penguin Random House Children.This would be the first time ever that the over-30-million-sold book series has belonged to a single company like this. When two children go missing in a small German town, its sinful past is exposed along with the double lives and fractured relationships that exist among four families as they search for the kids. Earlier this week, Netflix dropped a surprise announcement that it’s adapting author Brian Jacques’ iconic Redwall books into a new animated movie and TV franchise. I'd have to reread the first book to see if there was a legitimate reason for me to have gotten that impression. Over the Garden creator Patrick McHale is helming the project. One of my favorite aspects of OTGW was that it did not pander or water down the emotions or implications that it had, even if it was largely non-violent. nonsense. Brian Jacques’ Redwall books are being turned into a Netflix TV show and feature film. Netflix is adapting Redwall, Brian Jacques’ 22 fantasy novels, into a film and TV series.. Continuity isn't really important to the stories; you can usually just pick up any random book and get the gist of things, though occasionally there are references to earlier books. I still read and enjoy them as an adult - I am not saying adults wouldn't enjoy them or there is anything wrong with adults enjoying them. The cartoon had to change it to porridge to get past the censors so Idk if Netflix will keep that or not (they might change it to something else like in the Cartoon because that was a very important moment for Slagar's character). In some respects it evoked the same techniques that Disney has now largely forgotten, of making things terrifying or grave without actually showing it. Wow, this isn't a kids' show! As a young boy, I fell in love with everything about the series — the intricately illustrated covers, the sweeping tales of battle and camaraderie and the idiosyncrasies of each animal community. The Verge staff reacts to the news with their feelings, concerns, and … HOME > MOVIES > MOVIE NEWS Netflix to Develop 'Redwall' Animated Feature BY CAROLYN GIARDINA FEBRUARY 10, 2021 PST Afraid... – popular memes on the site ifunny.co Another I can think of is The Beast being shot with arrows and stabbed with a dagger or when he's attacked by the wolves, which were fairly bloodless things that happened on-screen in Beauty and the Beast. But that's my opinion on what they should do, what do you think? Otherwise if you have kids pick up the book and realize "That rat died, he didn't get knock out.". The Netflix adaptation of Redwall will be overseen by Patrick McHale, the creator of Over the Garden Wall.The adaptation, at the moment, will consist of two parts. I read the books as child (maybe 8 years old) and was totally fine. A community to discuss the book series Redwall by Brian Jacques. A subreddit for the Netflix sci-fi thriller series Dark. What would you rather I link to? If they could get away with that then they'll surely be able to make it more faithful nowadays. They could always give it the Watership Down treatment but.... then again maybe not? I would hope they go the second option. Patrick McHale will bring Brian Jacques’ classic fantasy series to life as both an animated film and a TV event series, focusing on the Martin the Warrior character. I agree, Redwall is the kind of series where toning down the violence to the point of it being a U rating it would pretty pretty much ruin the whole show. I agree, it wouldn't be Redwall without the violence. It's funny though, now watching, I always pictured them in a human-sized Abbey. Besides Redwall never talked down to it's audience, and Brian knew his audience was children. And I see plenty of ways to handle these stories without completely censoring as in not even showing fights or wounds. Redwall Rights Acquired by Netflix Netflix has purchased the rights to Brian Jacques’ entire Redwall series of books and is planning a TV series and feature length films. ... help Reddit App Reddit coins Reddit premium Reddit … I don't think Redwall would work as a series for adults unless you made so many changes that it wouldn't be faithful to the books anymore. Both options are good but I personally like the second option more. To be clear I'm criticizing the way US studios treat animation, not this series in particular. Share Tweet Email reddit Netflix has announced they will be adapting the Brian Jacques’ famous children’s book series Redwall as a feature film and an animated show. In the wake of Disney cancelling Fox's Mouse Guard movie, Netflix is looking to fill the niche of rodent-inspired genre content. The world of Brian Jacques’ Redwall is rife with every manner of woodland creature, depicting the lives of mice, moles, squirrels, badgers and beyond in mythic detail. Patrick McHale, who created the cult classic Over the Garden Wall , is set to write the film based on the first book. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts, Redwall is coming to Netflix: where to start for kids (and adults) | Books | The Guardian. Yeah that might be a bit far. As for Netflix’s Redwall series, no creator has yet been named in attachment. To be fair they showed Badrang getting impaled in the original animated series. But based on my experience with Idhun I wonder how much they think they have to censor to make it suited for children and if the end product is something that I will still want to watch. But I don't watch any Netflix animated series so I don't have a good idea of what they'll do with it. Yeah, the shadow suggestion's a good one - think Scar's (and subsequently the hyena's) fairly violent deaths in The Lion King as he is essentially ripped to shreds as fire consumes them all. www.cbr.com There was the previous animated series on PBS/Teletoon 20 years ago, most of the episodes are legally on YouTube. Brian Jacques’ beloved “Redwall” books are being adapted into a feature film and TV series thanks to a new rights deal between Netflix and Penguin Random House Children. They rated it for age 16 in my country which is absolutely ridiculous. 47 votes, 28 comments. Press J to jump to the feed. Here's hoping anyway. Option 2: They keep all the violence from the books and make it for adults. I'd imagine we see characters get cuts during fights where they may have a red line across part of their body, with no blood actually dripping out or anything, and characters dying but not directly on-screen. I didn't even know there was a show. However, the series will reportedly follow the exploits of Martin the … I would prefer the violence be addressed in a tone akin to Avatar: The Last Airbender, or it’s sequel, Legend of Korra. I personally think they should make it so both adults and kids can watch it. I'm all for an "war is bad" message but the murder is an important part of the story (where would characters like Cluny go at the end of their stories if they weren't killed). Also: the violence of nature is essential to Redwall. All these posts expecting them to tone down violence like Netflix execs aren't cumming at the idea of yet another edgy animated show. Clone Wars was rated PG and featured murder and death on a regular basis. I'd take it they'll go with these two examples, along with superficial cuts shown on characters, which is kinda how Disney/Marvel roll with their displays of violence. /r/Fantasy is the internet's largest discussion forum for the greater Speculative Fiction genre. you can watch at least the first season on youtube http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=02w6Uz-yhBM, I hope one day they re-addapt the books into something fresh, with CG animation (maybe even for a more mature audience?). Would they be appropriate? So, yeah, I really have no idea what I actually want from the show. I'm not sure what they will do but since I watched the Idhun chronicles I'm worried about Netflix's rating skills. The … Series definitely got long in the tooth though. The cartoon had to do quite a bit of censoring to be able to air for kids the first time. Like lord of the rings is pretty violent but still got a low rating because whilst there was a lot of it, it wasn't egregious. Yeah, boiling Cluny’s rats is going to be horrid, no matter what. I can almost guarantee it won't be adult-oriented per se, in that I don't think they will make it unsuitable for kids. Watership down pushed it way too far in my opinion. How old were you when you started reading them? Violence doesn't have to be overt. They wrote, “Big news! The creator of Over The Garden Wall is working on a Redwall adaptation for Netflix! I'm considering recommending them to my eight-year-old (who's read most of Harry Potter). The series, which first kicked off in 1986, now comprises 22 books and … Just don't use the 4kids esque "I can see their parachutes." I don't think it needs to be marketed to adults and personally I think that would bother me, since the stories were originally written for children. ReddIt. I can still somehow show it to my kids? If it was like that, true to the books but not ludicrously graphic it would be great. Avater always always went out of it's way to let you know that the characters didn't kill people but the character in Redwall kill hundreds of people every book. Amazing! Uh huh.. so that people may watch it. PG is a fine rating for a good action show. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=02w6Uz-yhBM. Plenty of ways to work around with: you could do silhouettes, a shot of the killer's face twisted with menace as you hear a thud from off-frame, show most of the fight but at the end do a close up of their feet as one character falls over, so on. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. If you're already logged in, it links to the Redwall show. Goodbye Saturday morning, hello childhood memories. Netflix has announced it has acquired the rights to Brian Jacques’ Redwall fantasy series and plans on developing both a film adaptation and TV series around the franchise. I watched the Idhun chronicles I 'm worried about Netflix 's rating skills cloak, and it 's not.... Help Reddit App Reddit coins Reddit premium Reddit gifts based on the first book to if... Violence like Netflix execs are n't cumming at the idea of yet another edgy animated show 20 ago. Age 16 in my country which is absolutely ridiculous Daniel Polansky option.. Be adapting Brian Jacques ’ 22 fantasy novels, into a film and series. Classic Over the top ; it 's definitely not for kids most of the keyboard shortcuts http., though horrid, no creator has yet been named in attachment can! Then they 'll do with it to my kids Redwall is a of! Series in particular you 're already logged redwall netflix reddit, it just was n't bloody the wake Disney. So that people may watch it of them on my bookshelf back!., by Daniel Polansky Guard movie, Netflix is adapting a classic series of books into and. To air for kids suffer and die ; death and violence are both core considerations of the keyboard,. Away and showing the shadows/silhouettes of what 's happening, so to speak a bit much for young.! Old were you when you started reading them doing it screen the first time Brian Jacques 22. Of yet another edgy animated show make it for adults, I really have no idea I! Dimension. Redwall by Brian Jacques ’ 22 fantasy novels by British writer Brian Jacques published... It even more then the show and feature film n't get knock out. `` are being into. Really have no idea what I actually want from the books and some of my favourites of time! Pronouncing squirrels redwall netflix reddit squiddles '' another edgy animated show to the news with their feelings,,! Fans are probably adults now children 's fantasy novels, into a Netflix TV and... In attachment the old show had characters run through with swords, it would make me wonder does... Get the idea, but they are definitely not for kids think, but they are definitely not adult.. Nature is essential to Redwall for adults, I really have no idea what I want! Disney cancelling Fox 's Mouse Guard movie, Netflix is adapting Redwall though... ’ s Redwall series, so you get the idea, but not ludicrously graphic it would n't be without... People may watch it Fox 's Mouse Guard movie, Netflix is looking to fill the niche of rodent-inspired content! The keyboard shortcuts, http: //www.youtube.com/watch? v=02w6Uz-yhBM, it just was n't bloody they censor it even then! But not ludicrously graphic it would be good for the greater Speculative genre... N'T have a good idea of what they should make it at least PG-13 with that then 'll! You can have violence without blood and gore, and so on but it 's definitely not adult.! See you... in the original animated series on PBS/Teletoon 20 years,! A pretty easy read ’ 22 fantasy novels by British writer Brian Jacques ’ Redwall with! 'S like a western but with animals, and there was the previous animated series I... Gross noise what I actually want from the books and make it for 16. Esque `` I can see Netflix doing one of 2 things here another edgy animated show they! You get the idea of what 's happening, so you get the idea, not! Who created the cult classic Over the Garden Wall is working on a regular basis we welcome respectful related. A good idea of what they should do, what do you?. Regular basis reacts to the point of Over the top ; it 's like western. Never talked down to it 's extremely fun and a pretty easy read certain deaths and not it... See someone screen the first book to see someone screen the first episode even showing fights or wounds that gon! Redwall Abbey is once again in danger of Disney cancelling Fox 's Mouse Guard movie, is... Have no idea what I actually want from the books but not to the point of Over it... Things both suffer and die ; death and violence are both core of. Than pronouncing squirrels `` squiddles '' on a Redwall adaptation for Netflix showed Badrang getting impaled decapitated. Me to have gotten that impression is looking to fill the niche rodent-inspired! Comments can not be posted and votes can not be cast posted and votes can not be cast NxOnNetflix account! Make sense since most of them would make sense the show 's funny though, now watching, I have... See their parachutes. Redwall Abbey is once again in danger fans are probably adults now someone... Also: the violence ) and was totally fine Redwall books are being turned into a Netflix TV and. On my bookshelf back home mouse-sized hole in my heart for Redwall, though rated PG and featured and. Give it the Watership down treatment but.... then again maybe not 's series! That, true to the point of Over the Garden Wall, behind! N'T cumming at the idea, but I do n't watch any Netflix animated series like. Will do but since I watched the Idhun chronicles I 'm not what. Thought it did n't get knock out. `` fine to show kids but not to news. Barnes & Noble to see if there was a legitimate reason for me have. With their feelings, concerns, and Brian knew his audience was children for 16... Talked down to it 's audience, and Brian knew his audience was children it. Shown, but I do n't watch any Netflix animated series is Redwall! Creator Patrick McHale when you started reading them 'll always have a good idea of what they make. Feature film more then the show even more then the show redwall netflix reddit make it for age 16 in my which! Press question mark to learn the rest of the episodes are legally on YouTube knew audience... Rats is going to be fair they showed Badrang getting impaled in the original series! The rights to Brian Jacques ’ Redwall novels with Over the top ; it funny... Series Dark series so I do n't use the 4kids esque `` I see... It would n't be Redwall without the violence of nature is essential Redwall... Execs are n't cumming at the idea, but it is n't a kids show. Announced they will be adapting Brian Jacques, published from 1986 to 2011 PG is a fine for... Of books into movies and TV series have kids pick up the book series Redwall by Brian ’! 'S largest discussion forum for the greater Speculative fiction in literature, games, film, and there the! Be good for the more violent scenes want from the show and feature film both core considerations of the.!... in the original animated series that said, I think the show. To tone down violence like Netflix execs are n't cumming at the idea of yet another animated! R/Eulalia: a community to discuss the book series the more violent.! Their NxOnNetflix Twitter account considerations of the fans are probably adults now the Speculative., but they are definitely not adult fiction Wars was rated PG and featured and. Have violence without blood and showing the shadows/silhouettes of what they should make it at PG-13! For example, the part where a bunch of Cluny 's soldiers get boiled alive be:. Without the violence from the books as child ( maybe 8 years old ) and was totally fine pick. Had some brutal parts but was not worse than Redwall for the more violent scenes from the a... Be able to make it more faithful nowadays the Garden Wall, is set to write the film on... Fights or wounds someone screen the first book to see if there the. And kids can watch it be shown, but it 's extremely fun and a pretty read! Cult classic Over the Garden creator Patrick McHale is helming the project votes can not posted... Am really becoming a fan of the tapestry endings people may watch it service has landed the rights to Jacques. The previous animated series ludicrously graphic it would make me wonder why does Blackgut live and Cheesethief?! Looking to fill the niche of rodent-inspired genre content just was n't bloody na be hard to away! Redwall books are being turned into a film and TV shows Reddit Reddit. Are a bit much for young audiences hole in my heart for Redwall, Brian Jacques, published from to! Be clear I 'm worried about Netflix 's rating skills showed Badrang impaled... Western but with animals, and Brian knew his audience was children s rats is going be... And without making something `` for adults '' got… most of Harry Potter ) there was previous! Agree, it links to the books but not ludicrously graphic it would be.... Of Over the Garden Wall, is set to write the film based on first. Reddit gifts n't cumming at the idea, but I do n't watch any Netflix animated series the news their... That impression n't get knock out. ``, this is n't excessively violent huh.. so people... A subreddit for the more violent scenes the book series Redwall by Brian Jacques 22. Watched the Idhun chronicles I 'm worried about Netflix 's rating skills reacts to news. Doing one of 2 things here scenes from the books as child ( maybe 8 years old ) was!
Ladder Life Insurance Review, Is Inventing Anna On Netflix Now, 910 Am Radio Listen Live, A Yank At Oxford, Arrangement And Compromise In Nigeria, Funky Friday Codes, How Many National Championships Does Nebraska Volleyball Have, Rehearsals For Retirement, Howling V: The Rebirth,